|
Articles » Computers >> View Article
|
|
|
"We Do Not Know What We Are Talking About" - Nobel Laureate David Gross
|
By:
Michael Strauss
|
|
|
|
|
|
Science has reached an enormous impasse. From biology to physics, astronomy to genetics, the scientific community is reaching the limits of understanding which often presage a complete rethinking of long-accepted theories. So characteristic of this new apex of modern arrogance is the inability to comprehend the obvious in physics: That we don't know what we are talking about.
Last December ('05), physicists held the 23rd Solvay Conference in Brussels, Belgium. Amongst the many topics covered in the conference was the subject matter of string theory. This theory combines the apparently irreconcilable domains of quantum physics and relativity. David Gross a Nobel Laureate made some startling statements about the state of physics including: "We don't know what we are talking about" whilst referring to string theory as well as "The state of physics today is like it was when we were mystified by radioactivity."
The Nobel Laureate is a heavyweight in this field having earned a prize for work on the strong nuclear force and he indicated that what is happening today is very similar to what happened at the 1911 Solvay meeting. Back then, radioactivity had recently been discovered and mass energy conservation was under assault because of its discovery. Quantum theory would be needed to solve these problems. Gross further commented that in 1911 "They were missing something absolutely fundamental," as well as "we are missing perhaps something as profound as they were back then."
Coming from a scientist with establishment credentials this is a damning statement about the state of current theoretical models and most notably string theory. This theoretical model is a means by which physicists replace the more commonly known particles of particle physics with one dimensional objects which are known as strings. These bizarre objects were first detected in 1968 through the insight and work of Gabriele Veneziano who was trying to comprehend the strong nuclear force.
Whilst meditating on the strong nuclear force Veneziano detected a similarity between the Euler Beta Function, named for the famed mathematician Leonhard Euler, and the strong force. Applying the aforementioned Beta Function to the strong force he was able to validate a direct correlation between the two. Interestingly enough, no one knew why Euler's Beta worked so well in mapping the strong nuclear force data. A proposed solution to this dilemma would follow a few years later.
Almost two years later (1970), the scientists Nambu, Nielsen and Susskind provided a mathematical description which described the physical phenomena of why Euler's Beta served as a graphical outline for the strong nuclear force. By modeling the strong nuclear forces as one dimensional strings they were able to show why it all seemed to work so well. However, several troubling inconsistencies were immediately seen on the horizon. The new theory had attached to it many implications that were in direct violation of empirical analyses. In other words, routine experimentation did not back up the new theory.
Needless to say, physicists romantic fascination with string theory ended almost as fast as it had begun only to be resuscitated a few years later by another 'discovery.' The worker of the miraculous salvation of the sweet dreams of modern physicists was known as the graviton. This elementary particle allegedly communicates gravitational forces throughout the universe.
The graviton is of course a 'hypothetical' particle that appears in what are known as quantum gravity systems. Unfortunately, the graviton has never ever been detected; it is as previously indicated a 'mythical' particle that fills the mind of the theorist with dreams of golden Nobel Prizes and perhaps his or her name on the periodic table of elements.
But back to the historical record. In 1974, the scientists Schwarz, Scherk and Yoneya reexamined strings so that the textures or patterns of strings and their associated vibrational properties were connected to the aforementioned 'graviton.' As a result of these investigations was born what is now called 'bosonic string theory' which is the 'in vogue' version of this theory. Having both open and closed strings as well as many new important problems which gave rise to unforeseen instabilities.
These problematical instabilities leading to many new difficulties which render the previous thinking as confused as we were when we started this discussion. Of course this all started from undetectable gravitons which arise from other theories equally untenable and inexplicable and so on. Thus was born string theory which was hoped would provide a complete picture of the basic fundamental principles of the universe.
Scientists had believed that once the shortcomings of particle physics had been left behind by the adoption of the exotic string theory, that a grand unified theory of everything would be an easily ascertainable goal. However, what they could not anticipate is that the theory that they hoped would produce a theory of everything would leave them more confused and frustrated than they were before they departed from particle physics.
The end result of string theory is that we know less and less and are becoming more and more confused. Of course, the argument could be made that further investigations will yield more relevant data whereby we will tweak the model to an eventual perfecting of our understanding of it. Or perhaps 'We don't know what we are talking about.'
About the author: Michael Strauss is an engineer who has an interest in this subject matter. To contact the author visit: http://www.relativitycollapse.com or http://www.relativitycollapse.net |
| Resources |
|
| Article Source : http://www.article-content-king.com
Tags:
|
Total Views :
1483 Word
Count Appx. :
884
Rating : 13
Related articles
Features Of Sony Vaio X
Sony officially unveiled its latest addition to the Vaio range, the X Series. Claiming the crown as the lightest and thinnest Vaio to date, this little thin and light laptop really is quite an impressive feat of engineering.
(read entire
article)
|
By: Gursel Batmaz | 30-12-2009 |
|
| |
|
|
| |
Best Web Design Practices for E commerce sites
You might have come across several web design tips and practices which are general in nature or you might have come across some best E commerce tips and practices which are programming oriented. The best way to make you understand the need for good we
(read entire
article)
|
By: RamaKrishna Reddy | 29-04-2009 |
|
| |
Promotional USB Drives: Flexible and Portable
Technology has progressed tremendously over the years and has simplified the way data can be stored and transferred from one computer to another in the absence of a network. From the earlier bulky and unreliable data storage devices
(read entire
article)
|
By: Gardner Wilkinson | 29-04-2009 |
|
| |
|
|
| |
|
|
| |
Trojan Horse
A Trojan Horse is a destructive program that masquerades as a harmless application. Unlike viruses, Trojan Horses do not replicate themselves, but they can be just as destructive. One of the most dangerous examples of a Trojan is a program that promise
(read entire
article)
|
By: Clive Haman | 16-11-2009 |
|
| |
Windows 7 Sominace is Threatened
Windows 7 sales are strong since its launch but with less PC sales and increased competition from several operating systems, the question arises would Windows be able to survive. Apple currently reported one of its best quarters ever, and interest is h
(read entire
article)
|
By: Stephanie tayla | 28-01-2010 |
|
| |
My PC Secret Formula
Save time, save money and boost your internet speed by leaps and bounds like no other system on earth can do. Over 14,000 copies and counting sold.
(read entire
article)
|
By: Bruce Hammond | 16-11-2008 |
|
| |
|
|
| |
Encryption – What Is It And Why You Need It?
Encryption refers to the process where files and messages are encoded to secure their contents. No one can understand an encrypted message without first decoding it. Only the person who has the key to decode it can get access to the file or the message
(read entire
article)
|
By: Run Lia | 11-01-2010 |
|
| |
|
|
| |
Importance of PDF Conversion
A Portable Document Format (PDF) is very important for all the business professional. It facilitates proper formatting without concern about software, hardware and operating system.
(read entire
article)
|
By: Bea Arthur | 24-06-2009 |
|
| |
Drawing Scanning Vs Paper Drawing
Drawing scanning is an important feature to save your drawings in less space for very long period. You can hire drawing scanning service to avoid capital investment in new technology scanners.
(read entire
article)
|
By: Ethan Allen | 27-07-2009 |
|
| |
|
|
| |
|
| |
 |
|
|
